Technology Issues - PG02-03 (Cycle 1) Game Ethics/Philosophy (03 October 2012)

PG02-03
---------------

Do Games need Value?
As long as the game is fun, nothing else matters...

Ethics - often mistaken for Morals

u: andrewcraddock_uk@yahoo.com
p: antepast18volscian

---

Make case to an ethical committee

Research had an ethical angle after the 2nd WW

---

Ethics -
not so materialistic

Morals -

Example of Social Values -
- Hackers
- Could be materialistic

---

Game - Spore
Does Ethics apply to games?

Ethical consideration with Multiplayer games?

Ethical issues with treatment of other players

As a Developer you have a responsibility

What is it that people overstep?

Does it affect the players morals? Virtual morals could be affected?

Do the moral choices encourage you to play again?

Henry Jenkins -
He looks at Good and Evil
- choice and consequences

Henry - looks at the choice of consequence
- the game should reflect the choice
- the games are constructed to define characters between Good and Evil
- can you feel guilty
- doesnt feel that it is a moral choice/multiple ending choice.
- just because someone does something evil, it is not evil

Have you played Against All Odds? - 1994
http://www.playagainstallodds.com/game_us.html

Where do we get Ethics from?
Society
Own experience
Parents
Teachers
Environment

Where are the boundaries?

Five cornerstones to Ethical behaviour

1. What are the consequences of the decision?
2. How can the option be implemented?
3. Decide which option is the most ethical
4. Consider your options
5. Think through the ethical dilemma and identify all components as objectively as possible

---

What does it create?
A working environment
Establishes a trust

Ethical behaviour creates public outrage

Dilemma
- The Principle of Psychiatric Confidentiality

Make a decision:
Remain silent

- consequence - they could kill the woman
- how can option be implemented? - not tell
- most ethical to respect the patient as they are paying, and confidentiality
- if not told, then the person is responsible for their decision
- however I would also recommend that they tell a social worker of their intent

---

morally closest answer - save daughter, inlaws might lose child

ethically closest answer

---

no right and wrong

---

Is the game work immune to ethical considerations?
- treatment of other players
- should your game affect the player's morales?
- if you integrated the morale choice, would it improve the game? - only if it is relevant
- do you think it is important to have in a game

- is the morale choice important? - depiction of real events
- Shooting Aliens
- Shooting people based on a historical conflict

---

Carmageddon - Is it a social value or moral value? - simulated violence

---

2st call - deadline for submission by 5pm today
2nd call

---

Philosophy - do we need to philosophize game cultures?

Monty Pthon Sketches
Arguement Clinic
Parrot Sketch

Can games

---
Lola

An eye for eye only ends up making the world blind

A computer will be considered intelligent if it can deceive a human into thinking that it is real

---

Make Love, Not Warcraft
South Park
http://vimeo.com/15715765

---

High debates going on in Low culture

---

Ask questions that no one else would ask.

Should the game have morals..

Nintendo's philosophy is never to go the easy path; it's always to challenge ourselves and try to do something new.
Shigeru Miyamoto
Read more at http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/keywords/philosophy_5.html#PsQRZtXLzxlyUFPI.99

---

"Freedom from fear" could be said to sum up the whole philosophy of human rights.
Dag Hammarskjold

---

Philosophy can create more value, more immersion.

---

Philosophy can add a new dimension to games, as ethical genres

---

What would the responsibility be? Can Star Trek can teach us about Time Travel?

Should the game play have a philosophical element? At the core or surrounding idea.

---

Bill and Ted's Bogus Journey - Looks at consequences of time travel

---

Identification of the Goal, implicate nature of philosophical.

---

*Watch Memento film - Time travel dealing with consequences, loss of memory, memory with photos. Can't survive without the photos. Tattoos as reminders.
Living life backwards, chopped scripts.

---

How do Games work as aesthetics and culture?

How do we understand philosophical game design?

---

*Play Heavy Rain - ethical decision making

---